Abstract
This paper examines the impact of generative AI (GenAI) on student cognitive engagement and learning processes. By synthesizing existing literature and drawing parallels with previous technological interventions in education, we analyze the potential benefits and challenges of AI integration in learning environments. The paper begins with a review of documented issues arising from the widespread use of internet search engines, calculators, and total recall devices (e.g., videos and photos) in educational settings. Building on this foundation, we extrapolate analogous concerns that may arise from integrating GenAI into learning processes, with a particular focus on the Google effect and the "illusion of understanding." Our investigation goes beyond merely highlighting potential negative impacts; we conduct a rigorous examination of empirical evidence supporting the purported benefits of AI use for cognitive engagement. This balanced approach allows us to present a nuanced perspective on the transformative potential of GenAI in education. This work contributes to the ongoing discourse on technology-enhanced learning and provides valuable insights for educators, policymakers, and researchers navigating the rapidly evolving landscape of AI in education.
Recommended Citation
Ballotti, R. J., Lu, S., Jiang, M., & Harter, D. (2026). Navigating Generative AI in Education: Balancing Benefits and Challenges in Student Cognitive Engagement. The Journal of Advancing Education Practice, 7(2). https://openriver.winona.edu/jaep/vol7/iss2/6
Included in
Cognitive Science Commons, Educational Psychology Commons, Educational Technology Commons
