Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is now integrated into daily academic life, yet doctoral students often decide how to use it without explicit guidance from universities, programs, or advisors. In this perspective paper, three doctoral students in Communication Sciences and Disorders, who are also practicing speech-language pathologists, reflect on our AI use during the first, second, and third years of our studies. We draw on cognitive offloading theory, which explains how individuals transfer aspects of mental work to external tools to reduce cognitive demand (Risko & Gilbert, 2016). While earlier technologies such as search engines and GPS primarily offloaded memory, generative AI can also offload reasoning and writing, which are central skills in doctoral training. Therefore, each of us discusses what we choose to offload to AI, what we retain for ourselves and our reasoning, and how these decisions have evolved as we progress toward independent scholarship. Collectively, we conceptualize offloading as a deliberate choice regarding where AI can augment intellectual effort rather than supplant it. We conclude that responsible AI use depends on the task, the stage, and the scholar’s judgment, and that open dialogue with advisors and peers helps doctoral students refine their boundaries.
Recommended Citation
Lawrence Wellman, A., Smith-McMillion, S., Mitchell, L. T., Zapata, M., & Harris, O. (2026). The Scholar Behind the Screen: Doctoral Students’ Perspectives on Navigating Generative AI While Preserving Scholarly Judgement. The Journal of Advancing Education Practice, 7(2). https://openriver.winona.edu/jaep/vol7/iss2/5
